Andrew Brody, host of the Princeton Review podcast, LSAT Logic in Everyday Life, ends every episode with a reminder for his listeners: “don’t get emotionally involved with the subject matter.” Brody’s advice applies to any situation in which you must apply critical thinking – that is, almost every situation. Remaining detached gives you multiple advantages in formulating and articulating an argument.
In your initial information gathering, staying above the fray helps you to cut through propaganda and recognize legitimate points. It also provides you with the necessary perspective to focus on your primary objective – convincing someone else that your reasoning is correct.
A level-headed approach will also make a better impression when you go to argue your case. You’ll appear to be more well-prepared and objective than if you pelt your audience with impassioned invective.
This is not to say that you cannot be passionate about a subject: a bit of flame, if measured correctly, can light all kinds of fires. The purpose of detachment is to ensure that your passions are dedicated to the truth above any personal agenda.
Staying detached usually means having to ask tough questions of yourself and of others. That’s a good thing, though – all the important discoveries in life begin with a willingness to sail in uncharted waters.